For many years, Josh Safdie and Benny Safdie were known as one of Hollywood’s strongest filmmaker pairs. Their intense and realistic films like Good Time and Uncut Gems earned global praise and changed modern independent cinema. Their fast-paced style, raw performances, and risky storytelling made them stand out.
However, in 2023, their partnership suddenly ended. At first, the reason was unclear. Now, reports suggest the breakup was linked to a serious incident from the past that slowly destroyed trust between the brothers.
The 2017 ‘Good Time’ Set Incident
The root of the conflict goes back to the shooting of Good Time in 2017. During filming in New York, a 17-year-old actress was cast in a sensitive role that involved nudity and simulated intimacy. She was acting opposite Buddy Duress, a non-professional actor with a troubled background.
According to reports, Duress behaved inappropriately during the shoot. The situation crossed professional boundaries and reportedly broke industry rules meant to protect minors. The actress was deeply affected by the incident.
Why the Scene Was Never Released
The controversial footage was later removed from the film before its premiere. Officially, the reason given was “creative changes.” However, insiders say the decision was taken to prevent further damage after concerns were raised about the actress’s age and safety.
At the time, the matter did not become public and remained hidden for several years.
Controversy Resurfaces Years Later
The incident returned to public attention in 2022 during a legal dispute involving the Safdies’ former producing partner. As court discussions and media reports brought back details from the Good Time set, new tensions emerged.
This was reportedly the first time Benny Safdie fully understood the seriousness of what had happened. The revelation caused a deep divide between the brothers.
Blame, Fallout, and Broken Trust
Following the renewed attention, blame was passed between former collaborators. Different versions of events surfaced, leading to arguments and damaged relationships. The Safdie brothers eventually ended ties with their production partner and began dissolving their shared company.
Though they tried to continue working together, the trust was already broken.
Netflix Project Cancelled
In early 2023, the brothers were working on a big Netflix project with major stars attached. However, after fresh media reports highlighted the old controversy, Benny Safdie decided to end the partnership completely.
The Netflix project was cancelled, marking the official end of the Safdie brothers as a filmmaking team.
Different Career Paths After the Split
After separating, both brothers focused on solo projects. Josh Safdie moved quickly and directed a high-profile film that received strong award-season attention. Benny Safdie chose a different route, working on a sports drama with a major Hollywood star.
The contrast in success added to public discussion, but industry insiders say the split was more about values and trust than competition.
Questions Around Filmmaking Ethics
The controversy has reopened debate about how far directors should go in the name of realism. The Safdies were known for pushing limits, using real locations, non-actors, and unpredictable situations.
Critics now question whether this approach ignored safety, especially for young performers. Child safety advocates have also spoken out, saying artistic ambition should never come before basic protection and dignity.
A Tragic End for One Involved
Buddy Duress, the actor involved in the original incident, passed away in 2023 due to a drug overdose. His death added another layer of sadness to an already troubling story.
Personal Relationship Also Broken
Despite public statements suggesting the split was professional, reports say the brothers are no longer close personally. They have been seen avoiding each other at social events, showing how deep the damage runs.
Conclusion
The Safdie brothers’ breakup is not just about creative differences. It highlights serious concerns about responsibility, ethics, and accountability in filmmaking. What began as a hidden incident eventually ended one of Hollywood’s most respected partnerships. The story serves as a reminder that success in cinema should never come at the cost of safety and trust.
FAQs
Why did the Safdie brothers split?
Their partnership ended after an old on-set incident resurfaced, leading to loss of trust and creative differences.
What happened on the set of Good Time?
A minor actress was exposed to inappropriate behavior during filming, raising serious safety and rule violations.
Why was the Netflix project cancelled?
The project was dropped after renewed media attention and internal disagreements between the brothers.
Are Josh and Benny Safdie still working together?
No, they are now pursuing separate careers and are reportedly not in contact.
What is the main lesson from this controversy?
Artistic ambition must always respect ethical boundaries, especially when minors are involved.