Halligan is a former insurance lawyer and had no prior experience as a prosecutor before taking on the high-profile role in Virginia. She gained attention for bringing cases against individuals considered adversaries of Trump, but both of her cases ended unsuccessfully.
Her legal and political alignment with Trump has been a significant part of her public profile, similar to other personal attorneys of the former president.
Why Halligan Left the Justice Department
Halligan stepped down after U.S. District Judge David Novak, a Trump appointee, stated that she was “masquerading” as the Eastern District’s top federal prosecutor. The judge noted that her lack of prosecutorial experience was unusual for such a role.
While Judge Novak allowed Halligan to avoid disciplinary action, he emphasized that her inexperience did not justify her presenting herself as a U.S. attorney.
Controversial Cases Against Trump’s Enemies
During her brief tenure, Halligan attempted to prosecute former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James.
-
Comey was accused of making false statements to Congress and obstructing an investigation.
-
James faced bank fraud and false statement charges.
Both indictments were dismissed by U.S. District Judge Cameron Currie, who said Halligan was unlawfully appointed and therefore had no authority to present the cases to a grand jury.
Trump’s Role in the Appointment
Trump appointed Halligan on September 20, 2025, after removing his first choice, Erik Siebert, who resisted pressure to prosecute Comey and James.
This move came after Trump publicly urged then-Attorney General Pam Bondi to proceed with investigations of Comey, James, and Senator Adam Schiff.
The appointment was widely criticized as politically motivated, and Halligan’s lack of prosecutorial experience became a focal point of legal scrutiny.
Current Status of Lindsey Halligan
As of now, it is unclear if Halligan has taken up another position within the Justice Department or elsewhere. She has officially left government service.
Her departure follows a similar case with Alina Habba, another Trump attorney, who was also disqualified from serving as acting U.S. attorney in New Jersey.
Expert Opinion
Legal analysts say Halligan’s appointment raises questions about the politicization of the Justice Department. Assigning inexperienced lawyers to critical prosecutorial roles can undermine public trust in the legal system.
Many also note that Trump’s influence in these appointments highlights the intersection of politics and justice, which may lead to further scrutiny of federal appointments in the future.
Conclusion
Lindsey Halligan’s brief tenure as interim U.S. attorney ended amid controversy over her qualifications and authority. Both her attempted prosecutions against political figures and her appointment by Trump drew widespread criticism.
The case reflects broader concerns about political influence in federal law enforcement and the importance of experience and ethics in key legal roles.
FAQs
Who is Lindsey Halligan?
Lindsey Halligan is a former insurance lawyer and a loyal supporter of Donald Trump. She briefly served as interim U.S. attorney in Virginia without prior prosecutorial experience.
Why did she leave her job?
A federal judge ruled that she was unlawfully serving as the top prosecutor and “masquerading” in the role, prompting her resignation.
What cases did she handle?
Halligan brought cases against former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James, but both were dismissed due to her unlawful appointment.
Was her appointment political?
Yes. She was appointed by Trump after her predecessor resisted politically sensitive prosecutions, leading to claims of political motivation.
Is Halligan working anywhere now?
As of now, it is unclear whether she has joined another role in the Justice Department or any other organization.